1. The "Goat in the Stable" Theory: This theory suggests that the phrase originated from the practice of putting a goat in a stable with a racehorse. The goat's presence supposedly calmed the horse and prevented it from getting nervous or agitated. If someone "got the goat," they were essentially stealing the horse's calming influence, causing it to become agitated and perform poorly.
2. The "Goat-in-the-Barn" Theory: This theory is similar to the first but suggests that the goat was put in a barn with a racehorse to prevent the horse from becoming distressed by the noise and activity during a race. If someone "got the goat," they were interfering with this calming influence and causing the horse to become anxious.
3. The "Gambling Scam" Theory: This theory suggests the phrase comes from a gambling scam where someone would steal a gambler's goat, which was used as collateral for a bet. This would cause the gambler to become enraged and lose their bet.
4. The "Goat as a Scapegoat" Theory: This theory suggests the phrase relates to the use of a goat as a scapegoat, a practice in ancient cultures. "Getting your goat" could mean causing someone to act as a scapegoat or to become the target of blame or anger.
5. The "Goat's Disruptive Behavior" Theory: This theory suggests that the phrase originated from the naturally disruptive behavior of goats. Goats are known to be curious and prone to mischief, and "getting your goat" could have referred to the act of being annoyed or bothered by a goat's antics.
6. The "Goat as a Symbol of Anger" Theory: Some speculate that goats were associated with anger or bad temperaments in folklore or superstition. "Getting your goat" might have represented someone making you lose your temper or becoming irrationally angry.
Which Theory is Most Likely?
While each theory has its supporters, there's no definitive evidence to confirm any of them. The phrase seems to have appeared in print in the early 20th century, and its meaning has evolved over time. The most popular theory, the "goat in the stable" theory, is compelling but lacks definitive proof.
Ultimately, the true origin of "to get your goat" remains a bit of a mystery.