This comment is incisive because it:
* Is brief and to the point: It gets straight to the heart of the issue.
* Offers a clear and specific critique: It points out the lack of innovation in the product line.
* Provides evidence to support the critique: It uses the company's own claims of commitment to innovation as a point of contrast.
* Is thought-provoking: It leaves the reader pondering the company's true priorities.
Here are some other examples of incisive comments:
* "The argument hinges on a flawed assumption that all people are inherently motivated by the same things." (Challenges a central premise)
* "Her latest novel lacks the depth and complexity of her previous works, relying too heavily on plot twists and superficial characters." (Offers a critical assessment of a work of art)
* "While he speaks passionately about social justice, his actions in the past suggest a lack of genuine commitment to the cause." (Contrasts words with deeds)
In general, incisive comments are characterized by their sharpness, clarity, and ability to provoke thought or challenge existing assumptions.