Do you agree with the contention that slang or street language of Harlem Bronx is as expressive Shakespeares English?

It's an interesting and thought-provoking contention! Comparing Harlem Bronx slang to Shakespeare's English is a fascinating exercise, but it's important to approach it with nuance.

Here's why the comparison holds some merit:

* Richness of Expression: Both Shakespeare's language and Harlem Bronx slang are rich with expressive power. Shakespeare used inventive wordplay, metaphors, and imagery to convey complex emotions and ideas. Similarly, Harlem Bronx slang relies on creative idioms, metaphors, and wordplay to capture the nuances of everyday life and express unique perspectives.

* Adaptation and Innovation: Shakespeare's language was a dynamic, evolving form of English that incorporated vernacular speech and slang. Harlem Bronx slang also adapts and innovates, constantly evolving to reflect the changing social and cultural landscape of the community.

* Community and Identity: Both Shakespeare's language and Harlem Bronx slang function as powerful tools for building community and defining identity. Shakespearean language united people through shared cultural understanding, and Harlem Bronx slang creates a sense of belonging and shared experience among its users.

However, it's essential to acknowledge the significant differences between the two:

* Formal vs. Informal: Shakespeare's language, while innovative, was primarily rooted in formal, written English. Harlem Bronx slang, on the other hand, is largely oral and informal, designed for everyday communication.

* Historical Context: Shakespeare's language reflects the norms and values of his time, while Harlem Bronx slang reflects the contemporary experiences and realities of the community.

* Literary vs. Everyday: While Shakespeare's language was used for both literary and everyday purposes, Harlem Bronx slang primarily serves as a means of everyday communication within the community.

Conclusion:

While it's compelling to draw parallels between Shakespearean English and Harlem Bronx slang in terms of their expressive power and ability to shape community identity, it's essential to recognize their distinct historical contexts and levels of formality. Both forms of language are vibrant and valuable in their own right, reflecting the creativity and adaptability of human expression.