Arguments for following punctuation:
* Clarity: Punctuation helps guide the reader through the flow of the poem, making it easier to understand the intended pauses, emphasis, and structure.
* Author's intent: The poet chose to use punctuation for a reason. Ignoring it could mean missing subtle nuances in the poem's meaning.
* Respect for the text: Treating the poem as a finished work of art means respecting the poet's choices, including punctuation.
Arguments against following punctuation:
* Rhythm and flow: Poems often have their own internal rhythm and flow that can be disrupted by strict adherence to punctuation.
* Emphasis: Punctuation can be used to create emphasis in prose, but in poetry, the rhythm, rhyme, and word choice often create their own emphasis.
* Personal interpretation: Some people believe that poetry is meant to be experienced subjectively, and punctuation can be interpreted in different ways.
Ultimately, the best way to read a poem is the way that makes the most sense to you. Experiment with different approaches, and see what works best for you.
Here are some tips for reading poetry:
* Read aloud: This can help you hear the rhythm and flow of the poem.
* Pay attention to the line breaks: These are often significant in poetry, marking pauses and shifts in thought.
* Consider the context: Think about the poem's form, style, and historical context.
* Don't be afraid to reread: Poetry can be rewarding to read multiple times.
Remember, there's no right or wrong way to read poetry. The most important thing is to enjoy it!