Mild:
* Poor
* Unsatisfactory
* Subpar
* Mediocre
* Disappointing
* Not good
* Lackluster
* Unfavorable
* Incompetent
Moderate:
* Terrible
* Awful
* Dreadful
* Horrible
* Abysmal
* Appalling
* Deplorable
* Disastrous
* Catastrophic
* Tragic
Strong:
* Despicable
* Reprehensible
* Heinous
* Abominable
* Devastating
* Degrading
* Monstrous
* Outrageous
* Unforgivable
* Criminal
Informal:
* Lousy
* Crap
* Rubbish
* Lame
* A disaster
* A nightmare
* A total bummer
Specific to situations:
* For health: "Poor condition," "Serious," "Life-threatening"
* For performance: "Substandard," "Inefficient," "Unacceptable"
* For behavior: "Inappropriate," "Disrespectful," "Unforgivable"
* For ideas: "Unsound," "Flawed," "Impractical"
Remember: The best word to use will depend on the specific situation and the message you want to convey.