However, there are a few notable instances where the phrase appears in early literature:
* 1923: In the play "The Firebrand" by Edwin Justus Mayer, a character uses the phrase "A concrete jungle, I call it."
* 1927: In the novel "Manhattan Transfer" by John Dos Passos, the phrase "concrete jungle" is used to describe the city.
* 1930s: The phrase was also used in popular songs and newspapers during the Great Depression.
Therefore, while a definitive origin remains elusive, "concrete jungle" likely emerged from the collective consciousness of urban dwellers during a period of rapid urbanization and societal change.