* Contrivance is a plot device where events occur solely to move the story forward, often without logical or realistic motivation. Think of it as a "deus ex machina" for the plot.
* Suspension of disbelief is the willingness of the audience to accept the fictional world and its rules, even if they are not entirely realistic.
Why Contrivance Hurts Suspension of Disbelief:
1. Breaks the Natural Flow: Contrivance often feels forced and unnatural. It interrupts the flow of the story, jolting the reader out of the immersive experience.
2. Undermines Character Agency: Characters might feel less like individuals with agency and more like puppets manipulated by the plot. This can make the story feel less emotionally resonant.
3. Reduces Stakes: If the story relies on contrived events to create conflict, the stakes feel artificial. The reader may not be as invested in the characters' struggles if they know the outcome is predetermined.
4. Creates Plot Holes: Contrivance can lead to plot holes and inconsistencies, as it often requires bending the rules of the story's world.
5. Diminishes Credibility: A story riddled with contrivances can feel unbelievable and amateurish, potentially alienating the reader.
Example:
Imagine a story where a character needs to find a rare ingredient for a potion. A contrived solution might be a sudden storm that washes a box containing the ingredient onto the shore, conveniently appearing right when the character needs it. This feels artificial and undermines the story's internal logic.
Instead of Contrivance, Consider:
* Organic Plot Development: Let events unfold naturally from character actions and motivations, creating believable consequences.
* Character-Driven Conflict: Focus on internal struggles and external obstacles that characters actively work to overcome.
* Well-Established Worldbuilding: Create a believable world with rules and limitations that characters must operate within.
Remember, a well-crafted story should feel believable and engaging. Contrivance can detract from these qualities, leaving the reader feeling unsatisfied and disappointed.